We use cookies to give you the best possible experience on our website. Carry on browsing if you’re happy with this, or see our Cookie Policy for more information.

Perfect New York style bagels

Delicious fluffy bagels to remind you of New York

Like this? Share it with your friends.

Report abuse

Makes 60 bagels;


1750g of Shipton Mill organic white flour

40g salt

10g barley malt syrup

970g of warm water (luke warm)

3.5g active dried yeast




1. Mix the salt and flour together in a stand mixer for a couple of spins

2. Meanwhile add the yeast and barley malt syrup to the water (stir and rest for three minutes)

3. Turn your mixer on a slow speed and slowly add the water (should take about 30 seconds to add)

4. Mix for 12 minutes.

5. Remove dough from the mixer and rest for 10 minutes

6. Cut the dough in to 100g portions. and shape them in to balls, tucking them in on themselves.

7. Put them in a proof tray or baking sheet (wise to put on baking parchment to avoid sticking) and leave at room temperature for 90 minutes, or until doubled in size.

8. Put them in the fridge overnight or for 12 hours.

9. Remove from the fridge and bring to room temp for 10 mins, meanwhile put a large pan of water on to boil. 

10. Grab a dough ball and carefully punch a hole in the middle with your fingers, then gently spin the bagel between your forefingers until a small hole is formed (turn the oven on to 220 degrees).

11. Once the water is at a rolling boil, add 3 bagels to the water at a time and poach on each side for two mins (four mins total)

12. Remove the bagels from the water with a holed spoon and place on the baking sheet - repeat this process for the max you can fit on sheets for your oven.

13. Bake for 6 mins then spin the baking sheet 180 degrees and bake for another 6 minutes

14. Check the colour, when they're golden brown they're ready (bake them for another 3-5 mins if you prefer a crispier crust).

15. Cool and enjoy!

Added by: Alex Hardie

Tags: Bread Seeds Bagels

Add comment

Add a recipe & get 15% off

If you add a recipe with a photo to the Shipton Mill website, we will send you a voucher for 15% off your next order from the Flour Direct shop.

15% off Flour Direct

It's very easy, just click here to visit your "My Shipton Mill" page to get started.

Flour Direct Shop update

Dear Customers,

Due to a temporary suspension of some services by couriers, we are currently unable to offer delivery to the Republic of Ireland, or overseas. This is being looked into urgently, and as soon as services resume we’ll update you here. Deliveries to Northern Ireland can now begin again.

If you live in the Republic of Ireland, please don’t order for the moment, as we are unable to get the order to you.


Keep safe and well

The Shipton Millers